「データベースは結論を得ない。」
角川文庫のベストセラー「古典部」シリーズ(米澤穂信 著)で
主人公の友達、福部智志の言葉。
フィギュアスケートの採点について
詳しく調べようと、過去の成績のデータをかき集めた。
たとえば、振付師による「CC(Choreography/Composition」への影響とか。
たとえば、PCSはどのように上昇していくのか。
などなど。
気まぐれに思える採点に、なんらかの法則を求めて、データを集めた。
しかし、そんな僕を、福部智志は、「さもありなむ」を笑うだろう。
データベースがいくら揃っても
次の大会の結果が解るはずもない。
しかし、世界選手権は目の前。
この不安な感じを何とか払しょくできないものか・・・
ということで、せっかく集めたので、データでちょっと遊んでみた。
シーズンベストとパーソナルベストなるものがある。
パーソナルベストは
トータルポイントとSPとFSのベストスコアはISUページですぐに見れるが
シーズンベストは見方がわからない。
SPとFSのスコアはTESとPCSの合算だから、
たとえば、Adam RIPPON ( USA ) 
Season Best Total Score 221.5  ( Four Continents Championships)
Short Program Total Score 74.92 ( Four Continents Championships)
Free Skating Total Score 146.63  ( Four Continents Championships)
しかし、
SP Total Element Score 39.79   (Four Continents Championships)
SP Components Score 36.54 (Grand Prix of Trophy Eric Bompard)
FS Total Element Score 74.96 (Grand Prix of Skate Canada)
FS Components Score 74.88 (Grand Prix of Trophy Eric Bompard)
↑この合算をすれば、
SP 39.79 + 36.54 = 76.33
FS 74.96 +74.88 = 149.84
76.33 + 149.84 = 226.17
よし!5点ほど、成績がアップした。
ホントのホントに実力を出せればこんな感じ?ってもんだ。
この調子で他の選手も計算しましょう。
Alexander MAJOROV ( SWE ) 
SP TSS  68.33( European Championships)
FS TSS  128.48( GP Trophy Eric Bompard)
Total    193.18( European Championships)
SP TES  36.29( European Championships)
SP PCS  32.04( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  68.33
FS TES  65.78( GP Trophy Eric Bompard)
FS PCS  63.56( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  129.34
Total Score (Real) 197.67
Alexei BYCHENKO ( ISR ) 
SP TSS  54.69( European Championships)
FS TSS  86.5( European Championships)
Total    141.19( European Championships)
SP TES  28.76( European Championships)
SP PCS  25.93( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  54.69
FS TES  42( European Championships)
FS PCS  45.5( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  87.5
Total Score (Real) 142.19
Ari-Pekka NURMENKARI ( FIN ) 
SP TSS  57.31( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS TSS  93.89( World Championships )
Total    149.91( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP TES  30.7( World Championships )
SP PCS  27.05( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP (Real) TSS  57.75
FS TES  43.59( World Championships )
FS PCS  51.6( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS (Real) TSS  95.19
Total Score (Real) 152.94
Artur GACHINSKI ( RUS ) 
SP TSS  84.8( European Championships)
FS TSS  161.47( European Championships)
Total    246.27( European Championships)
SP TES  45.91( European Championships)
SP PCS  38.89( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  84.8
FS TES  82.61( European Championships)
FS PCS  78.86( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  161.47
Total Score (Real) 246.27
Brendan KERRY ( AUS ) 
SP TSS  47.01( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  97.25( Four Continents Championships)
Total    144.26( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  24.91( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  23.1( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  48.01
FS TES  49.31( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  47.94( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  97.25
Total Score (Real) 145.26
Brian JOUBERT ( FRA ) 
SP TSS  67.92( European Championships)
FS TSS  139.91( European Championships)
Total    207.83( European Championships)
SP TES  31.07( European Championships)
SP PCS  38.85( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  69.92
FS TES  61.07( European Championships)
FS PCS  78.84( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  139.91
Total Score (Real) 209.83
Christopher CALUZA ( PHI ) 
SP TSS  58.02( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  114.58( Four Continents Championships)
Total    172.6( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  30.37( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  27.65( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  58.02
FS TES  52.78( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  61.8( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  114.58
Total Score (Real) 172.6
Daisuke TAKAHASHI ( JPN ) 
SP TSS  90.43( GP NHK Trophy)
FS TSS  172.63( GP Final)
Total    259.75( GP NHK Trophy)
SP TES  46.14( GP NHK Trophy)
SP PCS  44.29( GP NHK Trophy)
SP (Real) TSS  90.43
FS TES  87.05( GP Final)
FS PCS  90.28( GP NHK Trophy)
FS (Real) TSS  177.33
Total Score (Real) 267.76
Denis TEN ( KAZ ) 
SP TSS  77.73( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  140.99( GP Skate America)
Total    271.59( GP Skate America)
SP TES  43.44( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  35.29( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  78.73
FS TES  72.13( GP Skate America)
FS PCS  70.08( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  142.21
Total Score (Real) 220.94
Dmitri IGNATENKO ( UKR ) 
SP TSS  51.61( European Championships)
FS TSS  103.27( European Championships)
Total    154.88( European Championships)
SP TES  29.04( European Championships)
SP PCS  22.57( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  51.61
FS TES  57.43( European Championships)
FS PCS  46.84( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  104.27
Total Score (Real) 155.88
Florent AMODIO ( FRA ) 
SP TSS  78.48( European Championships)
FS TSS  155.7( European Championships)
Total    234.18( European Championships)
SP TES  39.87( European Championships)
SP PCS  38.61( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  78.48
FS TES  74.14( European Championships)
FS PCS  81.56( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  155.7
Total Score (Real) 234.18
Javier FERNANDEZ ( ESP ) 
SP TSS  84.71( GP Skate Canada International)
FS TSS  166.29( GP Final)
Total    250.33( GP Skate Canada International)
SP TES  45.6( GP Skate Canada International)
SP PCS  39.28( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  84.88
FS TES  85.48( GP Skate Canada International)
FS PCS  81.4( GP Final)
FS (Real) TSS  166.88
Total Score (Real) 251.76
Javier RAYA ( ESP ) 
SP TSS  51.98( European Championships)
FS TSS  112.7( European Championships)
Total    164.68( European Championships)
SP TES  26.12( European Championships)
SP PCS  26.86( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  52.98
FS TES  59.14( European Championships)
FS PCS  53.56( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  112.7
Total Score (Real) 165.68
Jeremy ABBOTT ( USA ) 
SP TSS  83.54( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS TSS  156.16( GP Final)
Total    238.82( GP Final)
SP TES  42.04( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP PCS  42.33( GP Final)
SP (Real) TSS  84.37
FS TES  74.8( GP Final)
FS PCS  83.44( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS (Real) TSS  158.24
Total Score (Real) 242.61
Jordan JU ( TPE ) 
SP TSS  49.49( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  85.48( Four Continents Championships)
Total    134.97( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  27.81( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  22.68( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  50.49
FS TES  43.42( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  43.06( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  86.48
Total Score (Real) 136.97
Justus STRID ( DEN ) 
SP TSS  54.71( European Championships)
FS TSS  101.62( European Championships)
Total    156.33( European Championships)
SP TES  29.09( European Championships)
SP PCS  25.62( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  54.71
FS TES  48.64( European Championships)
FS PCS  54.98( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  103.62
Total Score (Real) 158.33
Kevin ALVES ( BRA ) 
SP TSS  47.96( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  84.98( Four Continents Championships)
Total    132.94( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  25.4( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  23.56( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  48.96
FS TES  44.08( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  42.9( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  86.98
Total Score (Real) 135.94
Kevin REYNOLDS ( CAN ) 
SP TSS  68.22( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  140.1( GP Figure Skating Cup of China)
Total    204.41( GP Figure Skating Cup of China)
SP TES  34.36( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  34.86( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  69.22
FS TES  79.3( GP Figure Skating Cup of China)
FS PCS  69.3( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  148.6
Total Score (Real) 217.82
Kevin VAN DER PERREN ( BEL ) 
SP TSS  71.05( European Championships)
FS TSS  142.39( GP Skate America)
Total    257.59( GP Skate America)
SP TES  37.76( GP Skate America)
SP PCS  34.55( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  72.31
FS TES  74.61( GP Skate America)
FS PCS  67.78( GP Skate America)
FS (Real) TSS  142.39
Total Score (Real) 214.7
Kim LUCINE ( MON ) 
SP TSS  57.64( European Championships)
FS TSS  121.69( European Championships)
Total    179.33( European Championships)
SP TES  30.91( European Championships)
SP PCS  26.73( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  57.64
FS TES  63.11( European Championships)
FS PCS  58.58( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  121.69
Total Score (Real) 179.33
Laurent ALVAREZ ( SUI ) 
SP TSS  56.64( European Championships)
FS TSS  102.81( European Championships)
Total    159.45( European Championships)
SP TES  31.89( European Championships)
SP PCS  24.75( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  56.64
FS TES  48.89( European Championships)
FS PCS  53.92( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  102.81
Total Score (Real) 159.45
Maciej CIEPLUCHA ( POL ) 
SP TSS  54.17( European Championships)
FS TSS  112.69( European Championships)
Total    166.86( European Championships)
SP TES  29.41( European Championships)
SP PCS  24.76( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  54.17
FS TES  61.33( European Championships)
FS PCS  51.36( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  112.69
Total Score (Real) 166.86
Michal BREZINA ( CZE ) 
SP TSS  79.08( GP Skate America)
FS TSS  153.17( European Championships)
Total    229.3( European Championships)
SP TES  42.05( GP Skate America)
SP PCS  39.22( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  81.27
FS TES  74.15( European Championships)
FS PCS  80.02( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  154.17
Total Score (Real) 235.44
Min-Seok KIM ( KOR ) 
SP TSS  49.39( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  107.75( Four Continents Championships)
Total    157.14( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  24.64( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  25.75( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  50.39
FS TES  56.53( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  52.22( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  108.75
Total Score (Real) 159.14
Misha GE ( UZB ) 
SP TSS  64.49( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  132.04( Four Continents Championships)
Total    196.53( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  32.99( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  31.5( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  64.49
FS TES  63.04( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  69( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  132.04
Total Score (Real) 196.53
Nan SONG ( CHN ) 
SP TSS  76.53( GP Trophy Eric Bompard)
FS TSS  154.03( GP Figure Skating Cup of China)
Total    226.75( GP Figure Skating Cup of China)
SP TES  44.92( GP Trophy Eric Bompard)
SP PCS  32.11( Four Continents Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  77.03
FS TES  86.45( GP Figure Skating Cup of China)
FS PCS  67.64( GP Trophy Eric Bompard)
FS (Real) TSS  154.09
Total Score (Real) 231.12
Patrick CHAN ( CAN ) 
SP TSS  87.95( Four Continents Championships)
FS TSS  185.99( Four Continents Championships)
Total    273.94( Four Continents Championships)
SP TES  45.73( Four Continents Championships)
SP PCS  43.96( GP Trophy Eric Bompard)
SP (Real) TSS  89.69
FS TES  95.83( Four Continents Championships)
FS PCS  90.16( Four Continents Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  185.99
Total Score (Real) 275.68
Peter LIEBERS ( GER ) 
SP TSS  61.08( European Championships)
FS TSS  115.67( European Championships)
Total    176.75( European Championships)
SP TES  29.4( European Championships)
SP PCS  31.68( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  61.08
FS TES  61.61( European Championships)
FS PCS  55.06( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  116.67
Total Score (Real) 177.75
Samuel CONTESTI ( ITA ) 
SP TSS  66.86( European Championships)
FS TSS  145.86( GP NHK Trophy)
Total    212.32( European Championships)
SP TES  31.36( European Championships)
SP PCS  36.5( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  67.86
FS TES  74.52( GP NHK Trophy)
FS PCS  76.42( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  150.94
Total Score (Real) 218.8
Sergei VORONOV ( RUS ) 
SP TSS  61.15( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS TSS  136.04( GP Rostelecom Cup )
Total    197.19( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP TES  30.74( European Championships)
SP PCS  31.64( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP (Real) TSS  62.38
FS TES  74.15( European Championships)
FS PCS  67.84( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS (Real) TSS  141.99
Total Score (Real) 204.37
Takahiko KOZUKA ( JPN ) 
SP TSS  79.77( GP NHK Trophy)
FS TSS  155.25( GP NHK Trophy)
Total    235.02( GP NHK Trophy)
SP TES  40.88( GP NHK Trophy)
SP PCS  38.89( GP NHK Trophy)
SP (Real) TSS  79.77
FS TES  76.67( GP NHK Trophy)
FS PCS  78.58( GP NHK Trophy)
FS (Real) TSS  155.25
Total Score (Real) 235.02
Tomas VERNER ( CZE ) 
SP TSS  81.14( European Championships)
FS TSS  144.22( European Championships)
Total    225.36( European Championships)
SP TES  42.39( European Championships)
SP PCS  38.75( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  81.14
FS TES  67.06( European Championships)
FS PCS  78.16( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  145.22
Total Score (Real) 226.36
Viktor PFEIFER ( AUT ) 
SP TSS  53.58( European Championships)
FS TSS  115.34( European Championships)
Total    168.92( European Championships)
SP TES  27.83( European Championships)
SP PCS  26.75( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  54.58
FS TES  59.64( European Championships)
FS PCS  55.7( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  115.34
Total Score (Real) 169.92
Yuzuru HANYU ( JPN ) 
SP TSS  82.78( GP Rostelecom Cup )
FS TSS  166.49( GP Final)
Total    245.82( GP Final)
SP TES  45.2( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP PCS  37.58( GP Rostelecom Cup )
SP (Real) TSS  82.78
FS TES  87.21( GP Final)
FS PCS  79.28( GP Final)
FS (Real) TSS  166.49
Total Score (Real) 249.27
Zoltan KELEMEN ( ROU ) 
SP TSS  60.12( European Championships)
FS TSS  117.9( European Championships)
Total    178.02( European Championships)
SP TES  34.94( European Championships)
SP PCS  26.18( European Championships)
SP (Real) TSS  61.12
FS TES  58.98( European Championships)
FS PCS  58.92( European Championships)
FS (Real) TSS  117.9
Total Score (Real) 179.02
むむむ・・・・
さすれば、順位は?
1	Patrick CHAN ( CAN ) 	275.68 
2	Daisuke TAKAHASHI ( JPN ) 	267.76 
3	Javier FERNANDEZ ( ESP ) 	251.76 
4	Yuzuru HANYU ( JPN ) 	249.27 
5	Artur GACHINSKI ( RUS ) 	246.27 
6	Jeremy ABBOTT ( USA ) 	242.61 
7	Michal BREZINA ( CZE ) 	235.44 
8	Takahiko KOZUKA ( JPN ) 	235.02 
9	Florent AMODIO ( FRA ) 	234.18 
10	Nan SONG ( CHN ) 	231.12 
11	Tomas VERNER ( CZE ) 	226.36 
12	Adam RIPPON ( USA ) 	226.17 
13	Denis TEN ( KAZ ) 	220.94 
14	Samuel CONTESTI ( ITA ) 	218.80 
15	Kevin REYNOLDS ( CAN ) 	217.82 
16	Kevin VAN DER PERREN ( BEL ) 	214.70 
17	Brian JOUBERT ( FRA ) 	209.83 
18	Sergei VORONOV ( RUS ) 	204.37 
19	Alexander MAJOROV ( SWE ) 	197.67 
20	Misha GE ( UZB ) 	196.53 
21	Kim LUCINE ( MON ) 	179.33 
22	Zoltan KELEMEN ( ROU ) 	179.02 
23	Peter LIEBERS ( GER ) 	177.75 
24	Christopher CALUZA ( PHI ) 	172.60 
25	Viktor PFEIFER ( AUT ) 	169.92 
26	Maciej CIEPLUCHA ( POL ) 	166.86 
27	Javier RAYA ( ESP ) 	165.68 
28	Laurent ALVAREZ ( SUI ) 	159.45 
29	Min-Seok KIM ( KOR ) 	159.14 
30	Justus STRID ( DEN ) 	158.33 
31	Dmitri IGNATENKO ( UKR ) 	155.88 
32	Ari-Pekka NURMENKARI ( FIN ) 	152.94 
33	Brendan KERRY ( AUS ) 	145.26 
34	Alexei BYCHENKO ( ISR ) 	142.19 
35	Jordan JU ( TPE ) 	136.97 
36	Kevin ALVES ( BRA ) 	135.94 
くううう・・・・
結局、余計にあの人に盛ってしまったような。
さすれば、パーソナルベストなら、どうなるか?
順位だけを示すと、
1	Patrick CHAN ( CAN ) 	283.40 
2	Daisuke TAKAHASHI ( JPN ) 	277.45 
3	Takahiko KOZUKA ( JPN ) 	266.68 
4	Jeremy ABBOTT ( USA ) 	253.73 
5	Brian JOUBERT ( FRA ) 	252.68 
6	Javier FERNANDEZ ( ESP ) 	251.76 
7	Artur GACHINSKI ( RUS ) 	249.32 
8	Yuzuru HANYU ( JPN ) 	249.27 
9	Michal BREZINA ( CZE ) 	247.83 
10	Tomas VERNER ( CZE ) 	245.27 
11	Florent AMODIO ( FRA ) 	239.33 
12	Adam RIPPON ( USA ) 	238.55 
13	Samuel CONTESTI ( ITA ) 	234.19 
14	Kevin REYNOLDS ( CAN ) 	232.34 
15	Sergei VORONOV ( RUS ) 	231.97 
16	Nan SONG ( CHN ) 	231.12 
17	Kevin VAN DER PERREN ( BEL ) 	227.73 
18	Denis TEN ( KAZ ) 	227.07 
19	Peter LIEBERS ( GER ) 	206.05 
20	Alexander MAJOROV ( SWE ) 	197.67 
21	Misha GE ( UZB ) 	196.53 
22	Viktor PFEIFER ( AUT ) 	187.75 
23	Zoltan KELEMEN ( ROU ) 	182.00 
24	Kim LUCINE ( MON ) 	181.50 
25	Min-Seok KIM ( KOR ) 	177.95 
26	Christopher CALUZA ( PHI ) 	172.60 
27	Ari-Pekka NURMENKARI ( FIN ) 	170.88 
28	Maciej CIEPLUCHA ( POL ) 	169.14 
29	Javier RAYA ( ESP ) 	165.68 
30	Laurent ALVAREZ ( SUI ) 	159.45 
31	Justus STRID ( DEN ) 	158.33 
32	Dmitri IGNATENKO ( UKR ) 	155.88 
33	Brendan KERRY ( AUS ) 	145.26 
34	Alexei BYCHENKO ( ISR ) 	142.19 
35	Jordan JU ( TPE ) 	141.59 
36	Kevin ALVES ( BRA ) 	141.49 
さらに、面白くない結果になってしまった。
あの壁は、破れないのか・・・
いやいや、そうとばかり言えない。
そうさ。たかが、データベース。
データベースだけでは結論なんてでない。
日本男子は、あの鼻をへし折ってやるにいくのだ。
見てろよ。
[13回]
PR
         
                                        
この記事へのコメント